McBain Shield – Petone v Hutt Old Boys Marist 

Legendary All Black Billy Wallace described Alexander McBain as “the grandfather of school rugby.”

McBain was born in Scotland in 1868 and migrated to New Zealand in 1892. He was a schoolteacher for 45 years, culminating in his tenure as headmaster of Eastern Hutt School from 1915 to 1931. A leading referee, coach, and rugby advocate, he was the President of the Hutt Club and Vice-President of the Wellington Rugby Football Union. In 1933, he died. A year later, Hector McBain (Alexander’s son) and Thomas Bevan presented a Shield to the Hutt and Petone clubs to “foster good fellowship.”

The first ‘McBain’ was won by Hutt 6-5 in a tussle described as a “Homeric struggle.” Struggle is only a mild description of the difficulty Hutt would soon endure trying to prise McBain from the “Villagers.” Between 1953 and 1984, Petone won the Jubilee Cup 14 times and never relinquished McBain. So imperious was Petone that their third side often played and beat Hutt.

Record

Played: 91

Petone Won: 64

Hutt Won: 22

Drawn: 5

Under Seven Points: 40

Year Winner Score
1934 Hutt 6-5
1935 Petone 10-6
1936 Petone 3-0
1937 Petone 23-0
1938 Petone 12-7
1939 Petone 17-9
1940 Petone 16-12
1941 Drawn 8-8
1942 Petone 6-0
1943 Petone 9-6
1944 Drawn 11-11
1945 Petone 16-13
1946 Hutt 6-0
1947 Petone 33-6
1948 Drawn 3-3
1949 Petone 29-6
1950 Petone 6-3
1951 Petone 9-5
1952 Hutt 19-6
1953 Petone 14-9
1954 Petone 6-0
1955 Petone 29-6
1956 Petone 6-0
1957 Petone 6-3
1958 Petone 14-11
1959 Petone 21-11
1960 Petone 30-12
1961 Petone 46-11
1962 Petone 11-8
1963 Petone 11-5
1964 Petone 14-6
1965 Petone 11-3
1966 Petone 29-6
1967 Petone 34-8
1968 Petone 26-6
1969 Petone 28-11
1970 Petone 23-16
1971 Petone 19-6
1972 Petone 41-10
1973 Petone 23-7
1974 Drawn 0-0
1975 Petone 39-6
1976 Petone 38-8
1977 Petone ?
1978 Petone 23-6
1979 Petone 10-9
1980 Petone 10-6
1981 Petone 22-0
1982 Petone 37-6
1983 Petone 15-14
1984 Petone 18-11
1985 Hutt 4-3
1986 Petone 38-3
1987 Drawn 18-18
1988 Hutt 10-7
1989 Hutt 13-4
1990 Petone 30-9
1991 Hutt ?
1992 Petone 51-5
1993 Petone 40-15
1994 Petone 18-16
1995 Petone 43-13
1996 Hutt 34-25
1997 Hutt 18-15
1998 Petone 22-16
1999 Petone 32-16
2000 Hutt 21-18
2001 Hutt 40-17
2002 Hutt 19-8
2003 Hutt 22-20
2004 Hutt 27-17
2005 Hutt 25-23
2006 Petone 26-16
2007 Petone 26-16
2008 Petone 16-13
2009 Petone 15-0
2010 Petone 41-22
2011 Hutt 27-20
2012 Hutt 43-22
2013 Hutt 50-22
2014 Petone 20-19
2015 Hutt 32-25
2016 Petone 27-23
2017 Petone 49-31
2018 Hutt 30-27
2019 Hutt 46-26
2020 Petone 32-24
2021 Hutt 35-26
2022 Petone 27-20
2023 Petone 49-32
2024 Petone 48-31
2025 Hutt 30-25
2026    
2027    
2028    
2029    
2030